Does Scripture contradict Mary’s Immaculate Conception?

Dave Armstrong

Though the Immaculate Conception of the Blessed Virgin Mary isn’t explicitly mentioned in the Bible, the Church’s longstanding teaching is harmonious with Holy Scripture, and is supported by both analogy and plausibility. Consider:

Luke 1:28 (RSV): “And he came to her and said, ‘Hail, O favored one, the Lord is with you!’” [in the RSV – Catholic edition, “favored one” is rendered as “full of grace”]

Many translations use “favor” here, yet even the great Baptist Greek scholar A.T. Robertson (Word Pictures in the New Testament, Vol. II, 13) agrees that the word involved (kecharitomene) means “full of grace which thou hast received.” It’s derived from the Greek root, charis (literally, “grace”).

Now, a Catholic asks, “what does it mean to be full of grace?” For St. Paul, grace is the antithesis and overcomer of sin:

Romans 6:14, 22: “For sin will have no dominion over you, since you are not under law but under grace. … But now that you have been set free from sin … the return you get is sanctification and its end, eternal life.”

Moreover, we are saved by grace:

Ephesians 2:8: “For by grace you have been saved through faith; and this is not your own doing, it is the gift of God” (cf. Acts 15:11; Rom 3:24; Titus 2:11; 3:7).

Therefore, it follows, I submit, that for a person to be full of grace is to both be saved and to be exceptionally, completely holy. Therefore, Mary is holy and sinless. The essence of the Immaculate Conception is sinlessness, and this is deduced from many biblical passages about the antithetical relation of grace to sin, and salvation and its accompanying sanctification to sin.

The only remaining question is: when did God apply this grace to Mary? We know she possessed it as a young woman, at the Annunciation. Catholics believe that God gave her the grace at her conception so as to avoid the original sin that she inevitably would have inherited, being human, but for God’s preventive grace, which saved her from falling into the pit of sin.

But do we ever observe in the Bible other individuals being extraordinarily sanctified, even before their birth? Yes; for example, the prophets Isaiah and Jeremiah:

Isaiah 49:1, 5: “… The LORD called me from the womb … And now the LORD says, who formed me from the womb to be his servant …” (cf. Job 31:15, 18; Jud 16:17).

Jeremiah 1:5: “Before I formed you in the womb I knew you, and before you were born I consecrated you; I appointed you a prophet to the nations” (cf. Sirach 49:7).

“Consecrated” or “sanctified” (KJV) in Jeremiah 1:5 is the Hebrew word quadash. According to Gesenius’ Hebrew-Chaldee Lexicon of the Old Testament (p. 725), in this instance it meant “to declare any one holy.”

Jeremiah was thus consecrated or sanctified from the womb; possibly from conception. This is fairly analogous to the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception. We know Jeremiah was a very holy man, and perhaps even sinless. We also have New Testament evidence of such sanctification before birth (John the Baptist and St. Paul):

Luke 1:15: “(F)or he will be great before the Lord … and he will be filled with the Holy Spirit, even from his mother’s womb” (cf. 1:41, 44).

Galatians 1:15: “… he who had set me apart before I was born, and had called me through his grace …”

We know that John the Baptist was also a very holy man. Was he sinless? We can’t know that for sure from the biblical data. St. Catherine of Siena, for one, believed that he never sinned (A Treatise of Prayer). But we do know for sure that he was sanctified from the womb.

Therefore, by analogy and plausibility, we can and may conclude that it is “biblical” to believe in faith that Mary was immaculately conceived. Nothing in the Bible contradicts this belief. It does require faith, of course. God restored to Mary the innocence of Eve before the Fall, and filled her with grace, in order to prepare her for her unspeakably sublime, sanctified task as the Mother of God the Son.

Dave Armstrong has been a published Catholic apologist since 1993. Dave has written or edited 48 books on apologetics, including several bestsellers. If you’d like to help keep his influential teaching apostolate going as a much-needed monthly supporter, write to Dave at [email protected]